Tough Christmas Conversations

Ch 7 interview with Michelle Mitchell Tough Christmas Conversations

PRESENTER: For many families, December 25 can be a really tricky time. On the one hand, you want to give your kids a festive season with all the trimmings. On the other, the bank balance can stop you dead in your tracks. But a rich Christmas doesn't always mean big presents under the tree; making lasting memories can go a long way. So if times are tough, how can you set realistic expectations for your children without feeling like the Grinch? For more, we welcome author and parenting educator Michelle Mitchell back to the Morning Show. Hi, Michelle, lovely to see you. Children will naturally compare what they get for Christmas with their friends. What's the psychology behind it?

MICHELLE: The reward centre of our kids' brains is really active, and this is why they compare so much. They want to feel good all the time. Christmas gifts obviously make them feel good, but comparing those gifts with their friends adds another layer. If they get a present and their friends say, "Oh wow, I wish I got a present like that," it's almost like a double layer of feeling good. It's called a social reward or a status reward, and from about nine and up, their brains really seek those status rewards. What I want parents to know is that there's never going to come a time when their reward centre says, "Now, Mum, I've had enough status rewards, you can stop spending money now." It's a bottomless pit, and parents need to realise this. It's not going to care about their bank balance or their credit card debt.

PRESENTER 2: The sad reality, in particular this year, is that so many kids won't be getting the Christmas Day of their dreams, right? How can parents manage expectations around that?

MICHELLE: I think it's really important that parents have the freedom to chop things up. I was just talking to a mum the other day, and I said, "Why don't you just start the day completely differently?" Instead of going straight to the tree, which isn't going to have as many gifts around it as normal, let's go to the beach. Let's get in the surf, have breakfast by the beach and take some great photos. That's going to boost those positive brain chemicals. There are other ways we can satisfy the reward centre of our kids' brains other than gifts.

PRESENTER: Okay, so what are the things parents should avoid saying? What are the no-nos? What if Mum or Dad has lost their job, and there's not as much money in the house? Is it okay to say, "There's not going to be as many presents as usual, because Mummy's lost her job"?

MICHELLE: We don't want to transfer feelings of inadequacy or disappointment onto our kids, so we want to avoid that. We want to avoid saying, "Just be grateful for what you've got, there are all these kids around the world who don't have anything." And probably avoid blaming the big man in red. Let's leave him out of it. But we actually can see these moments as ways to invite our kids into the adult world in an age-appropriate way, and assume that our kids need to and want to talk about money. One thing that's really important too is not to shut down our kids' wants, dreams and desires. We might say to our kids, "There are some things I can't afford to buy this year, but that doesn't mean I don't want to talk to you about them." So let's talk about the things our kids would love to have for Christmas and work towards them in some way, even if we can't magically produce them.

PRESENTER 2: I suppose if Christmas Day is a problem for you, then the school holidays are a bigger problem as well. You've got the cousins going off to Hawaii, the friends going off to Bali. How do you manage that?

MICHELLE: It is a massive expense for families. Set a budget, give kids the calculator and help them make decisions about how to spend that money. Maybe set criteria: we're going to spend money as a family on the things that bring us joy, that have value, and that give us bang for our buck. And it would be sensible too to make a list of things that don't cost a lot of money, really low-budget things to do that help balance that out.

PRESENTER: But okay, the kids want to go to the Gold Coast theme parks and you can't afford that, and they're about 10 and 12. Is it okay to say, "Our budget doesn't let us stretch that far, but let's come up with some other ideas"? I'm a bit confused. Is it okay to say that or not?

MICHELLE: Of course it is. A parent might say, "It's my job to make sure we don't just have money for today, but for every day." And watch kids rally around a parent they know is doing it tough. When they know a parent is doing their absolute best to show up for them, kids get really protective and very loving of that parent.

PRESENTER 2: The trick, too, is that kids would probably love hopping on a ferry or going to the beach and taking stuff with them. If you asked them, just spending time with their parents could be a good thing, right?

MICHELLE: Absolutely. Parents are time-poor as well, but if we really recognise that time with our kids, words of affirmation, and making an activity special because we're fully present actually fulfil the reward centre of our kids' brains in the same way we think rich, materialistic Christmases do.

PRESENTER: A tricky time for a lot of families, and a lot of families are very anxious about it. So, great information. Thanks for coming in.

MICHELLE: My pleasure. Good to see you.

PRESENTER: Get more parenting tips from Michelle Mitchell's book, Tweens. It is out right now.